Caesarean sections 'are causing thousands to lose babies'

By | January 7, 2019

caesarian NHS health mother birth

C-sections are causing thousands of women to lose babies (Image: Getty Images )

In what experts describe as a “tragedy” and “hidden disaster”, some women lose multiple babies before doctors realise that a c-section for their first child may be to blame. Doctors who perform the procedure late can inadvertently make an incision low in the womb which weakens the woman’s cervix, according to Professor Andrew Shennan, one of the country’s leading experts on premature birth. This makes it more difficult for women to hold an unborn baby in subsequent pregnancies.

Often, women don’t even need a c-section, according to the professor, from King’s College London, who is due to publish his findings in a medical journal later this year.

Caesareans in the second stage of labour have become increasingly common.

But Prof Shennan believes ‘Women go multiple pregnancies before that the trend is having a “devastating” effect on women, who are then six times more likely to suffer a subsequent miscarriage or premature birth.

A series of studies carried out by Prof Shennan – who is also the director of the Prematurity Research Centre at charity Tommy’s – show that 14 percent of women who have a late stage c-sections go on to have a subsequent premature birth.

caesarian NHS health mother birth

Caesareans cause up to 1,000 premature births every year from which babies 500 will die (Image: Getty Images)

‘Women often go through multiple pregnancies before they find out what the problem is’

In contrast, only two per cent of women who did not have a late stage c-section have a premature baby.

His research also showed that previous caesareans cause up to 1,000 premature births every year.

Of these children, 500 will die while many others will suffer problems such as brain damage, blindness or deafness because of early delivery.

Most premature births occur before the baby is 32 weeks, and many happen before 24 weeks, when the baby is old enough to survive.

caesarian NHS health mother birth baby

Most premature births occur before the baby is 32 weeks (Image: Getty Images)

Prof Shennan claims that many doctors are opting to carry out late c-sections instead of using forceps or other instruments because of the mistaken belief it is safer.

He also said “just a handful of consultants” were currently aware of the issue and called for “new guidelines”.

The professor added: “Many people are unaware of the tragedy of the fact women are recurrently losing babies because they are not being appropriately referred or seeking appropriate help during a delivery.

“Doctors really need to be aware of this problem.

caesarian NHS health mother birth newborn

Caesareans in the second stage of labour have become increasingly common (Image: Getty Images)

“Many senior doctors – even consultants who qualified in recent years – avoid using forceps and other instruments to assist in delivery because of the mistaken belief this is less safe but this is not the case.

“Once doctors stop doing assisted deliveries or do fewer, they rapidly de-skill, making it harder for them to judge when it is appropriate to do or how to properly carry them out.”

Prof Shennan said he saw women affected by the issue in his clinic “every week”.

He said: “They often go through multiple pregnancies before they find out what the problem is. This will be by luck, very often.

caesarian NHS health mother birth

NHS England revealed that it is working to make improvements to its services (Image: Getty Images )

“What is dreadful is that there will be women out there who give up after numerous attempts, unaware of the cause, and that help could have led them to carry a child to term again.

Last night, NHS England revealed that it is working closely with Prof Shennan to make improvements to its services.

Matthew Jolly, national clinical director for maternity and women’s health, said: “These research findings will help obstetricians provide best practice care when a caesarean section at full dilatation is required.

“As part of the long-term plan for the NHS, we want to build on the excellent work across the country to make maternity services in England among the safest in the world.”

CASE STUDY

‘I lost three babies after having our little girl was rushed to hospital with bleeding and told she was losing her baby.’

Baleena Mattu, 35, had her first child nearly a decade ago but went on to lose three unborn babies, two at 19 weeks and one at 20. 

The property consultant said: “It is devastating when it happens so many times and after each one people tell you it can’t possibly happen again.

The doctors couldn’t explain why, having gone full-term with my daughter Kyira in 2010, I should have lost the next three so early on.

“Kyira was laying in the wrong position and the obstetrician said they would need to do a caesarian section to get her safely out. I agreed. It was an emergency operation but everything seemed to go well.”

childbirth case study caesarian

NEW DIAGNOSIS: Pregnant Baleena Mattu, with husband Harmail and daughter Kyira (Image: Zachary Culpin/Solent News)

In 2011 Baleena fell pregnant again but was rushed to hospital with bleeding and told she was losing her baby.

She lost two more before a new consultant suspected the problem was related to her c-section delivery. 

“He said he was confident the next time I got pregnant I could go to full term. He explained what had happened to me and offered a stitch in my cervix to strengthen it so that it was less likely to give way.”

Now 31 weeks pregnant, Baleena is due to give birth in spring.

She said: “Having had it happen to you three times, I couldn’t believe it when the weeks went by and I was still pregnant. Being pregnant still at Christmas 

Daily Express :: Health Feed